A heated debate has emerged in Kenya’s drama scene following reports that Echoes of War, a play by Butere Girls High School, may be barred from advancing to the National Drama Festival. The play, which clinched third place in the Western Region Drama Festival, is now under scrutiny from unnamed ministry officials who are allegedly seeking to block its performance at the national level.
Echoes of War delves into the ever-widening gap between the older and younger generations, particularly in how each approaches problem-solving and decision-making. The play portrays young characters (representing Gen Z) boldly demanding their rights, organizing protests, and pushing for a greater role in governance and societal decision-making.
This aspect of the play has reportedly unsettled some ministry officials, who claim it could incite youth activism. They argue that the play promotes rebellion rather than constructive dialogue, a perspective that has sparked outrage among students, drama enthusiasts, and freedom of expression advocates.
Echoes of Shackles of Doom
The controversy surrounding Echoes of War is reminiscent of the 2013 drama Shackles of Doom, written and directed by former Kakamega Senator Cleophas Malalah. That play was initially banned for its politically charged themes, only to be later allowed on stage at the National Festival in Mombasa after significant public outcry.
Similarly, Echoes of War has captivated audiences, particularly at the Western Region Drama Festival held at Chavakali Boys High School, where its gripping storytelling and stellar performances received high praise. Despite its success, some officials now seek to silence it, citing concerns over its underlying message.
Voices of the Youth: A Call for Change
Students who watched the play have strongly defended it, arguing that it accurately reflects their struggles and aspirations.
“The older generation still thinks we are children, incapable of making decisions for ourselves,” said Amos, a student who attended the festival. “In reality, we are capable and should be given opportunities to contribute to society.”
Another student, Aisha, drew parallels between the play and recent youth movements.
“Just like the Gen Z revolution, our concerns are being dismissed instead of being addressed. Instead of appreciating the play’s message, they want to ban it. We are no longer in the Stone Age!” she said.
Their sentiments reflect a growing frustration among young people who feel sidelined in national conversations and decision-making processes.
A Political Play or a Reflection of Society?
Opponents of the ban argue that the play is not political but rather a mirror of contemporary societal issues. Speaking in a phone interview, Senator Cleophas Malalah defended Echoes of War, dismissing claims that it promotes political propaganda.
“This play reflects real issues in our society and should be allowed to proceed,” Malalah said. “Labeling it as political is simply an excuse to suppress artistic expression.”
His stance aligns with concerns raised by critics who argue that censorship in the drama festival stifles creativity and denies students an essential platform to engage with real-life issues.
A Standout Performance at the Western Regionals
At the regional competition, Echoes of War received widespread acclaim for its compelling narrative, strong character portrayals, and thought-provoking themes. Drama enthusiasts praised the play as well-researched, engaging, and relevant to Kenya’s socio-political landscape.
“The acting was outstanding, and the message was powerful. This is the kind of storytelling that makes drama festivals meaningful,” said one festival attendee.
Many expected the play to be a formidable contender at the National Drama Festival in April. However, the looming ban now threatens to derail its progress.
Censorship in the Drama Scene: A Recurring Trend
This is not the first time the Kenyan school drama festival has faced controversy. Over the years, plays addressing sensitive topics such as governance, corruption, and social justice have often been censored or forced to undergo script modifications.
Critics argue that such actions undermine the role of drama as a medium for education and critical discourse. Others believe officials are wary of plays that highlight uncomfortable truths about governance and societal inequalities.
With Echoes of War already attracting significant attention, there is mounting pressure on the Ministry of Education and festival organizers to allow it to be performed at the national level without interference.
What Lies Ahead for Echoes of War?
As the National Drama Festival approaches, all eyes are on Butere Girls and whether they will be granted permission to stage their play. If past incidents are anything to go by, the debate over Echoes of War may intensify, especially if public outrage grows, similar to the Shackles of Doom case in 2013.
For now, supporters of the play, including Senator Malalah, remain hopeful that reason will prevail and that the students will be given a fair chance to showcase their talent.
Will Echoes of War face the same fate as Shackles of Doom, initially banned but later reinstated? Or will it be permanently blocked from reaching the national stage?
One thing is clear: school drama in Kenya is no longer just about entertainment—it has evolved into a powerful medium for storytelling, societal reflection, and, inevitably, controversy.
About the Author
